There’s a mixture of emotions in Tashkent tonight – knowing full well that there is everything to play for in this final match in the 3rd and most important round of World Cup Qualification. Both teams have been struggling for a number of months now, both needing a result to book that (next to) last ticket to Russia 2018. Uzbekistan v Korea was shaping up to be an epic showdown. Except that all who witnessed the 1st half saw a less than epic match. It was in fact – abysmal football. Inerrant passing, dispossessed dribbling, players running amok – it was Korea v Iran anti-football – but even worse. Had it not been for Uzbekistan competing for the worst team on the pitch, Korea would’ve been sunk. Uzbekistan even rattled the post. Nerves were shaken at the Tavern and for Taeguk Warrior supporters worldwide, yet another shambolic performance from Korea -so much so that despite coming close for Hwang hitting a crossbar in the 2nd minute and Son’s shot careening off the post in the dying embers before halftime, there was a growing feeling that the turning point for the utter destitution of Korean football (that gradual decline we’ve been witnessing for quite some time) was here at last. A hypothetical Uzbek goal was all that was needed to send Korea either into the 4th round of WCQ quagmire, or worse yet -with Syria getting goals in Tehran, getting knocked out altogether and missing out in the big game for the first time since 1982. Seeing Koo Ja-Cheol getting sent in for an injured and ineffectual Jang Hyun-Soo near the half, that perhaps inadvertently gave Shin’s side a reboot.
During the break, Shin Tae-Yong reorganized his confident-less squad and in the 2nd half, Korean football was ticking again, some would even go as far as to give a glimmer of looking somewhat resuscitated. Successful take ons, swashbuckling runs, fluid passing was back in fashion and Korea was enjoying a run of form and keeping the Uzbeks on their heels. Chances were taken and shots starting firing in. I’m getting ahead of myself, let’s take a step back and look at the starting XI, quite a different composite and formation from last Thursday at Seoul.
South Korea starting XI vs Uzbekistan pic.twitter.com/bPtD4SN699
— Jae (이재혁) (@ArmchairRegista) September 5, 2017
Shin lines up a 3-4-3 formation – but again without Ki as the midfield glue, had trouble getting out of the gate. It didn’t help that Jung Woo-young and Jang Hyun-Soo was passing almost directly to Uzbek players (Jang also showing off his lack of finishing in front on net – for the 2nd time in 2 games had a great opportunity with a corner kick and sent a shot in front wide. Lee Keun-Ho and Son Heung-Min weren’t doing themselves any favors getting dispossessed often. Ko Yo-Han and Kim Min-Woo both were ineffectual in the first half, however both improved in their wide roles as the game wore on, more successful than not in moving the ball down the flanks. As we mentioned before, Koo came in for Jang and without coincidence, the 2nd half looked much brighter for team Korea. Shin’s next move was to replace Kwon (who was a bit anonymous and partly responsible for some of the team’s atrocious passing, particularly in the final third) with the stalwart veteran Yeom Ki-Hun. Good build up plays resulted in shots coming in from Kim Min-Woo, Hwang Hee-Chan, Lee Keun-Ho, and Son Heung-Min. Uzbekistan was losing the narrative and conceding more space for the charging Koreans to maneuver in. Each shot seemingly closer to goal than the last. Shin will have plenty to defend in his first two games in charge, but one improvement from the Iran match: he didn’t opt for the Kim Shin-Wook “Plan B.” And yet, there was still no goal from all of that work. Sensing Lee Keun-ho’s ineptitude and poor touches on the ball through out the match, Shin pulled the trigger to his “Plan C” which conceptually be arguably as bad an option as “Plan B”: in the 77th minute Lee Dong-Guk, the 38 year old came on for Lee Keun-Ho. Korean Footballers Abroad jokingly/or seriously tweeted:
We go down to 10 men as the ghost of Lee Dong Guk comes on
— Korean Footballers (@KoreaFootAbroad) September 5, 2017
The one job he was sent to do was to score – and the old man did just as he did against Iran, he wasted his opportunities. Hwang lofted the ball to the “Lion King” – bringing him one on one with Uzbekistan’s keeper. He hit it straight at him. The ball rebounded to Son, his shot with several defenders swarming -went wide. Probably Korea’s best chance of the night. And with that, armed with the knowledge that the next goal would likely win World Cup qualifying with an eye on the Syria/Iran game, Uzbekistan countered with all their might, earning a knuckle biting free kick in Korea’s half with the dying seconds of stoppage time. Korea cleared it and the whistle blew. FT with a scoreless draw – Shin’s 2nd game in charge – no goals scored despite numerous chances, but no goals conceded. However it still wasn’t completely over: drama shifts over to Tehran as Syria had been ahead – shockingly the only team in the 3rd round to score on Iran – only to see Iran equalize. That game had 2 more minutes left. For Korea, the calculus to qualify depended on Iran’s ability to defend and prevent Syria from scoring 2 more times – otherwise they would be the 3rd place team and Syria would leapfrog them to automatically qualify for Russia. For Uzbekistan, after not seizing the opportunity to get 3 points at home against Korea – drawing instead nil-nil – their hopes and chances for whatever might await in the 4rd round was simply for that scoreline to remain. Then this happened less than a minute after the FT whistle in Tashkent as a hush drew for Uzbek supporters:
Holy smokes, Syria just scored in stoppage time in Iran—and as it stands it's Syria to the playoffs, South Korea to WC & Uzbekistan out.
— Grant Wahl (@GrantWahl) September 5, 2017
A miraculous last minute 2-2 comeback away in Tehran for the war strapped Syrians – a very tough place to play and the impossible happened. Syria remain alive in WCQ for round 4 to face Australia -and for the Uzbeks, for what seems like the 3rd or 4th time in a row, their hopes once again dashed. A decent squad in Asia…but missing out in the big show. Across Uzbekistan you could hear the sounds of hearts breaking.
For the Koreans, the Tehran result still meant qualifying – for the 9th consecutive time and 10th overall (the incredible haniljeon victory that qualified them for World Cup 1954). Handshakes and hugs and…what is that feeling exactly? A sense of relief? Or is it that queasy feeling that history is repeating itself, that Korea once again falls backwards (stealing Tavern headline from 2013) and still manage to qualify for the World Cup ? Two lackluster performances, two 0:0 draws, missed opportunities and a scoring drought – leaving it to Iran in the closing seconds and facing a team in even worse form to help Korea in barely eeking out a 3rd round automatic qualification in Group A. Glass half full: qualifying is qualifying and Korea did earn it, thanks to earlier results from round 3 and points – rather unconvincing points and yet difficult nail biting points in the scoreless draws. Another odd factor: though it might not ‘feel’ like Korea is capable of scoring these days, the statistics from Round 3 surprisingly shows Korea as the team having scored the MOST amount of goals in Group A. I’ll have to get the Tavern Statistician to draw up who scored and where they took place. But what about Iran? They were good in terms of getting results and notching first in the group, but their strength wasn’t in goal scoring but a nearly rock solid defense that didn’t allow any goals in Round 3 (except against Syria somehow). Many of their matches ended 1:0. Glass half empty: plenty of empty in this cup. And too many talking points to support this from this Round 3 to dredge up at the moment.
The story of how Korea will do in Russia 2018 is still unwritten and it would be unwise to write off team Korea – though they need drastic improvements to avoid a repeat of what happened in Brazil in 2014. If you said Korea looks incapable of going deep in the tournament, you would have little trouble finding others like minded in that assessment. But 9 months is a ways from now. I can’t predict the future, but if certain factors were to fall in place, say a Lee Seung-Woo tearing it up in Serie A, Suk Hyun-Jun making his umpteenth comeback in his career by making waves in Ligue 1, and K-League + other Asia based players finding their groove (dare we say a Jeonbuk-ish defense that is so on the same wavelength with the benefit of being in the same club system, the defensive problems from Round 3 may seem like a distant memory), or some other x-factor in this upcoming season -the perceived low expectations for this current squad may be the ace in the hole kryptonite that brings down unsuspecting ‘giants’ in the upcoming World Cup.
Where does Korea go from here?
For now, there is a gap in what the Korean public sees as progress in Korean football and the teetering infrastructure that supports development of football in Korea. The remarkable accomplishments of World Cup 2002 and advancing from group stage in the 2010 World Cup is something taken for granted by many in Korea, all while K-League stadiums grow weeds and the cricket sounds grow louder with each passing season. That horrendous pitch at Seoul World Cup stadium is in some ways, more indicative and damning of the state of Korean football than the team that failed to break down a 10 man Iran last Thursday. That K-League revenue stream at the ticket office and TV revenue is drying up at a time when the J-League and CSL are accruing increasing largess of TV broadcasting money is absurd and ludicrous, especially in light of the number of Asian Championship titles won by Korean clubs over the years. I have to wonder, where are the future Park Ji-Sungs, Cha Bum-Kuns or Lee Young-Pyos going to come from when the average freshman K-Leaguer is playing to a paltry salary and a nearly empty stadium every week? It’s difficult to say whether Korea having barely qualified for the World Cup represents an opportunity to move forward or a continuation of mediocrity and a slow decline with each World Cup cycle. Perhaps not qualifying might have given that shock to the system for the public to demand a reboot and a shot in the arm to Korean football? I’m talking about reforms that could give youth proper professional development opportunities rather than amateur college football (a failed model that also sets back progress for young players in the US). A chance to restructure ownership of K-League clubs so that they can invest and organically grow back it’s support base – in turn better marketing hand in hand with an MLS inspired move to smaller sleeker and sensible stadiums to improve atmosphere and attendance and better TV viewership. Sustainable revenue could allow clubs to compete, buy foreign players and offer competitive salaries for Koreans leaving for better pay in less competitive environments in China and the Middle East. Perhaps a plausible compromise/solution is more possible to the mandatory military conscription issue that has stalled Korean footballers in their prime, seeing how people power toppled a corrupt Park Guen-hye administration (yes, North Korea is still a problem, thus deferred military service can be a realistic alternative that allows Korean football to be internationally competitive and strikes a sensible balance with national security concerns). That’s a whole lot of changes and it can’t happen overnight – but it has to start somewhere -or the decline that we’re witnessing will continue.
But Korea did qualify. That effect can alert the country – as in “hey, all you fairweather baseball fans…Korea is in the World Cup again. Dig out your Red Devils support gear from the attic and dust it off. Get ready to have a party.” But what I really hope is that regardless of how Korea does next June – if people really do support the KNT now and in the future – then for Koreans to find their K-League team and rediscover them. Read K-League United and get fired up. Their blog is killing it and have scored impressive interviews with FC Seoul’s Dejan and other big name K-Leaguers. Find ways to support – if you are in Korea and your local club is hosting an Asian Champions League game, don’t neglect them (see Japan and China – they’re coming out in droves to support their teams- they got flags – they got drums – they’re out gunning Koreans in voice and song). However if no reforms happen, if the decline in attendance and everything else goes on unabated – the calculus for the dwindling youth population (apparently not enough young couples are having a sexy time – get on that!) is that more and more will come to the conclusion that there is no future in playing football -at least not in Korea. Should that time happen, Shakespeare’s line in Julius Cesare will be apt: “The fault, dear Brutus, is not in our stars, But in ourselves.”
HWANG HEE-CHAN was my man of the match —
more to come later…. Workrate, moving the ball around, dribbling through the opposition, passing, shots on goal, he did everything but score. Korea looked more likely than the hosts in finding the back of the net and were perhaps unlucky not to do so. Had Korea gotten a goal, Hwang would’ve been responsible in either creating it or finishing it himself.
Son Heung-Min continues to struggle for the national team —which can only mean one thing: an even better season for Tottenham than last year’s record breaking season (which saw Son break Cha Bum-Kun’s 30 year old goal scoring record for a Korean playing top flight Euro ball). Seriously though, Son has carried his own mental blocks and demons since last summer’s Olympics, failing to advance to a medal game and a lost opportunity at getting military exemption. He addressed the media post match and had confidence that the offense will improve in time for next summer’s World Cup.
Korea is the only team outside UEFA/COMNEBOL to be present in the World Cup since 1986. Korea’s 9th consecutive time qualifying sets a record for a team from the AFC. Augsburg and Tottenham sent congratulatory tweets to Koo and Son respectively.
끝까지 함께! 대한민국!
대한민국 축구 국가대표팀이 “2018 러시아 월드컵” 본선 진출을 확정지었습니다.
마지막 최종예선 경기까지 함께 해주신 대한민국 축구팬 여러분께 감사드립니다.#대한축구협회 #2018러시아월드컵 #끝까지함께 pic.twitter.com/Tow72awxnp
— 대한축구협회(KFA) (@theKFA) September 5, 2017
Be on the lookout: I’ve got a post I’ve been hinting at for some time about Son Heung-Min, something the European press has gotten wrong concerning his prospects of earning military exemption via medal win. I’m hoping this will get published in the next 2 weeks. I’ll also write about interesting data from the world of US baseball that actually has some relevancy with KPA’s like Son, Hwang, Kwon Chang-Hoon and others plying the trade in Europe -and how long distance traveling effects performances when called up for the national team in games played in Asia. Stay tuned. In the meantime, we can expect the KFA to line up respectable friendlies in October for the next international break to tune up for Russia 2018.
OH yeah, I almost forgot: last Thursday when Korea faced Iran, the Tavern turned five years old. The Tavern started slinging drinks after an inspiring Olympic Bronze medal win over Japan in August 2012 – that was when Park Chu-Young took on 4 Japanese defenders in the first half to net a jaw dropping goal and Koo Ja-Cheol scored a cheeky 2nd half goal to win military exemption. Ki, Koo, Ji all continue to play in Europe thanks in part to a hunk of metal that lifted the shackles of military conscription from limiting their careers. Perhaps it’s time for Nam Tae-Hee to join his compatriots in Europe too?
But at the same time
Korea barely qualify once again and as much as I’m happy and excited to spend some money on a uniform for the World Cup next year that’s for Korea, I am worried about what could potentially happen at the tournament.
Sure we didn’t concede these past two matches but we didn’t score either.
I have mixed feelings lol
Team Korea congrats but at the same time you guys need some serious reconstruction.
I like how you framed that – reconstruction. I may steal that for future articles.
Haha sure Roy!
I tend to agree with Roy on almost everything, but I wouldn’t describe today as heartbreak.
The team qualified. They set up in a weird shape, the 4-4-2 indicated they were happy with a draw. We didn’t concede too many chances, we should have scored a few. The job was done. Ugly, yeah. Uninspiring, yeah. Worrying, yeah. But we still made it.
My bad, I meant for readers to eventually find out it would be Uzbekistan who would suffer heartbreak. Heart attack for Koreans would be more like it. I may rename this post anyway…
This is the Tavern of the Taeguk Warriors! Who care about Uzbekistan and the emotions of Tashkent! Or for that matter, the Boston Red Sox, SEC football, or the New England Patriots!
HAHAHA! You’re damn right. I figured I’d let readers try to figure out the heartbreak thing -but it was too confusing. All right – post has been renamed
Haha, sorry to be critical!
I didn’t real diagonal and went through the post properly this time, so while we’re having a brief moment to celebrate another qualification, let me just say: Roy – your writing style is awesome, and I’m looking forward to your next contributions. Drinks for Roy everyone.
Also, we kind of had a Tavern birthday that went unnoticed the last week, so drinks for everyone!
Stop asking for my ID, Tavern bartender, we can probably break some rules for today only, right?
no, not at all – I didn’t think you were sounding critical. The title was misleading in a way and needed to be changed. New title: Heart Attack in Tashkent: Korea Crosses the finish line to qualify, yada yada… Oh yeah, in all the nervousness of this qualification bizness, I forgot about the Tavern’s birthday! Cheers / gom-pey!
Roy Ghim you’re the man! And a non-conventional spelling for your last name to boot!
Thanks Kevin. My unconventional spelling? Blame my dad –he was a stickler to proper pronunciations so he made up his own romanizations for Ghim as a family name.
Gosh I hope Jang Hyunsoo doesn’t start for the team ever again
Yeah. I don’t remember the last time Jang Hyunsoo played well. He always so turnover and mistake prone.
I don’t think a change to a new system was a good idea by STY. They already had major chemistry problems. Having to adapt to a new system didn’t help. Yeom Ki Hun definitely needs more minutes. He was only one who actually made some good decisions. Playing Lee Dong Guk didn’t seem like a bad idea. With little time left and at a crucial time of the game, adding a veteran to the lineup that can be a leader and calm things down seemed like a good idea. His finishing was poor, but he got in good positions to score.
Yo man, both Jang and Jung Woo-Young. I’ve seen both play better than this, so I hesitate to write them off completely, but if I had to base future KNT appearances on this game alone, I’d rather not call them up.
I think everyone knew even before these two games that a lot of work needs to be done before next summer. Really the performances weren’t that important, it was just about doing enough to get through, and they did it.
Looking forward, there are a few rays of hope. I thought Kim Min-jae and Hwang Hee-chan were excellent and looked like they’ve been playing international football for years. Almost everyone was poor in the first half, but there were some good performances in the second. The full-backs got forward well and the team had a much better balance with Koo. Jung Woo-young was the one player who really looked out of his depth for me.
agreed , especially Jung Woo-Young. Bad on the optics watching him play
On the bright side, Shin was hired to right the ship and ensure Korea’s qualification to the 2018 World Cup in Russia. While the results were far from inspiring, he and the rest of the team were able to accomplish that goal. We can all now breathe a collective sigh of relief that we don’t have to go and play Australia home and away in October and then, if we were to beat Australia on aggregate (which is hardly an easy feat), the fourth place CONCACAF team in November.
There are some encouraging takeaways from the past two matches: the KNT secured two clean sheets, one on the road and the other against an Iran side that was held scoreless only two other times in 10 matches. While the defense still experienced a few lapses (to be expected from the KNT), the backline inspired a bit more confidence than in the past. Hwang really emerged as the viable striker option that this team had been looking for. Let’s not forget that Shin took over the team two months ago, Ki was out injured, and Ji DW was out as well. This all put a lot of pressure on Son who generally plays better when he has a stronger supporting cast, versus when he has to shoulder all of the burden of having to create the scoring chances.
The two things I was wondering was why Koo didn’t start and why Lee Jae-sung was kept on the bench. Also, Nam TH was left off the bench entirely. Maybe I’m misremembering but I always thought Nam was a consistent presence in our side.
I suppose at this point we can briefly celebrate our ninth consecutive WC qualification. And then the KNT needs to focus on regrouping for next summer. Yonhap reported that the KNT was looking to schedule a couple friendlies during the October international break, so that will be the next opportunity to impress. Let’s hope that Ki can get healthy, find his form, and finding a spot in the starting XI at Swansea. Can Chungy find playing time at CP? One can hope. And let’s see how Suk HJ does at Troyes… Last but not least, we’ll monitor how Lee SW adjusts to life at Verona. While 2018 will be way too early for him to make an impact, it would be valuable experience for him to see what playing in that atmosphere is like for 2022.
well said, good observations there. Yeah, I was also surprised at Koo not starting. I might’ve been ok with injecting a slightly revised lineup from thursday -but Lee Jae-Sung would’ve been a super sub. Nam – also not sure why he was left off – I think he could’ve made impact – while deep mid is not his preferred role, I think Nam could’ve played Ki’s role far better than Jung Woo-Young. Shin should take some heat on his selections and his sub choices – but for me it’s not to throw him under the bus but to learn from all that -and hope for a fast learning curve. Piggybacking what you said: the fascinating narrative that could emerge in the next few months in the run up to Russia 2018 could be something like Chungy and Suk resurrecting their football careers and finding their form at their clubs – thus finding their way back to KNT. Lee Seung-Woo balling at Verona, or even Lee Jin-Hyun becoming a revelation at Austria Wein (that hasn’t happened yet -no jinx but that would be great for Shin to increase his portfolio of options). Ki, Ji, Koo, Son having solid productive season in europe and staying healthy would boost confidence for KNT I would imagine. Who the hell knows, Park Joo-Ho miracle in finding time w/ BVB 1st squad could be in the cards (not bloody likely but stranger things have happened).
They’re in, there’s no heartbreak?! Now it’s a matter of getting the right players ready. There’s still time. And hey, Team Korea hasn’t given up goals against the 2 of the best teams in their division with their new coach!
agreed, there’s still time for improvement. Mexico barely qualified for WC 2014, but surprised everyone in Brazil, looked dangerous and invigorated. 2017 KNT should (hopefully) be strengthened.
Hwang Hee Chan starting at forward it is. He was probably playing around 85% due to his knee injury? With more playing time with his club, he’ll only gain more confidence as the World Cup approaches.
So what’s going to happen with STY?
Apparently, Guus Hiddink (the manager of the South Korean team in the 2002 world cup) said he’s willing to come back. A couple of football/soccer fans here seem to like the idea, since he Hiddink did manage the team that managed to get the country’s best ranking in history (4th place) in the world cup.
It’s pretty unlikely at this late stage in the tournament, but what do you guys think? What options do we have left?
I don’t think it’s possible for him to come back even if he wanted to or cuts his salary. Judging by how KFA has been acting and acted in the past, they will continue with STY at least to the World Cup. It would be nice if he came back and restructure our team, but for now STY is our best hope.
We can maybe hope for a quality, foreign coach after the World Cup.
This is one of the best post I’ve read in the Tavern. Thank you for the insight and showing your perspective.
Thanks Bobby! Appreciate!